I will be in a similar situation. Never bought anything other than Lexus/Toyota. What brands are you considering? One issue I have encountered is the way some other brand dealerships treat customers (hospitality, attitude, openness to concerns, etc). For example, in my area, Mercedes sucks. It is even worst than a mass market brand.
In a related note, Lexus just won 2020 What Car? Reliability award.
The old CT200h got a perfect 100% reliability score in the previous 12 months, while it got 99% and 93,3% for up to 5 years old and from 6 up to 15 years respectly (for the entire range).
Source: https://blog.lexus.co.uk/lexus-awards-2020/
As a side note, this post should make @internalaudit smile since he’s getting a used CT 😎
I know some people like how Infiniti looks. I personally think their cars look good too. I don't really know why people are buying acura.. they probably think they are as reliable as Lexus.
For the more knowledgeable, SH-AWD but that Sports Hybrid SH-AWD will be appealing to me once offered in future Acura BEVs. Electric motors with torque vectoring are going to be a blast.
Definitely Acura reliability is not as good as it once was but its past motors were made to last -- 02 Civic at 273,000 km still runs fine and 11 Accord with 142,000 km still driving like 90% new. Manual transmission on the Civic still good and on the original clutch.
There is little reason to buy them over the competition or anyone if they are not even reliable. That used to be a Japanese hallmark and a good selling point for them. They both already have enough issues with the brand, now they are not even reliable. What a disaster.