NYT: More Luxury Buyers Ditch the Imports and Pick Up a Truck

Messages
3,165
Reactions
3,785
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/15/automobiles/wheels/luxury-trucks-suv.html
When Lee Victorian was looking for an upscale car to complement his wife’s BMW last year, he was leaning toward an Audi A6 — a sedan whose acceleration, refinement and dazzling array of advanced technologies, like automatic braking and radar-based cruise control, he found alluring.

But what he drove off the lot was an entirely different kind of premium vehicle, and one more luxury buyers are choosing: a pickup truck.

Mr. Victorian, a retired Michigan state trooper, bought a Raptor version of the Ford F-150. The Raptor is a truck with the soul of a racecar: It has a 450-horsepower engine, a 10-speed transmission, electronic ride settings for seven different road surfaces, big chrome wheels, a power tailgate, cameras at all four corners and an adaptive cruise control system similar to the Audi’s. With all those options, the sticker price came to about $80,000.

“Man, this truck is so slick,” Mr. Victorian said. “I stop at a light and people give me the thumbs up and take pictures of it. The truck is the celebrity.”

For the last few years, the auto industry has been roiled by a significant shift in consumer tastes. In droves, Americans are turning their backs on family sedans and small cars and flocking to bigger, roomier models like sport utility vehicles and trucks. In January, two of every three new vehicles sold were classified as trucks, including S.U.V.s, pickups, minivans and the lighter cousins of S.U.V.s known as crossovers.

Now a new dimension to this trend is emerging: Even upscale buyers who long favored Lexus, Cadillac, Jaguar and the German luxury brands are gravitating to trucks and S.U.V.s. What they are buying are often special-edition, fully loaded models, like Mr. Victorian’s Raptor, that sell for as much as or more than BMW’s flagship 7 Series sedan.

“We are seeing it,” said Tom Libby, an auto industry analyst at the research firm IHS Markit. “There is movement from luxury cars to luxury trucks.”

General Motors’ GMC brand — which sells only trucks and S.U.V.s — accounted for 11.3 percent of domestic sales of models with an average price of $60,000 or more in 2017, according to data from Edmunds.com. Five years earlier, the brand made up a mere 0.1 percent of those sales.

Ford and Chevrolet saw similar but smaller jumps, driven by increasing high-end truck and S.U.V. sales. At the same time, the portion of over-$60,000 sales for luxury brands including Porsche, Mercedes-Benz, Lexus, Jaguar and Cadillac shrank.

That is providing a tailwind for the Detroit automakers when overall new-vehicle sales in the United States are slowing. General Motors, Ford and Fiat Chrysler, with its Jeep brand, dominate in trucks and S.U.V.s, and now they’re scrambling to roll out more high-end versions.

It’s a competitive — and crucial — segment. With demand for cars shriveling, the Detroit three and even some foreign manufacturers acknowledge they are now losing money on many of the cars they sell. But a $60,000 truck can generate tens of thousands of dollars in operating profit.

At a recent investor conference, G.M. outlined a plan to produce more of the pricey Denali versions of GMC S.U.V.s and trucks. The company showed data indicating that the Denali line had an average sale price of $56,000 — more than the average price of a BMW, a Mercedes-Benz or an Audi.

“This thing,” G.M.’s president, Dan Ammann, said of the Denali line, “is a money machine.”

The other Detroit carmakers are heading in the same direction.

In October, Ford began making new versions of its eight-passenger Ford Expedition and Lincoln Navigator full-size S.U.V.s, and already has decided to make 25 percent more this year than it originally planned. In January, Navigators sold for an average of $77,000, thanks to strong sales of the top-of-the-line Black Label edition.

Fiat Chrysler is preparing to add more Jeep models, including a pickup and a full-size Grand Wagoneer.

In 2017, S.U.V.s and crossovers made up 41 percent of the market in the United States, up from 30 percent in 2013, according to Autodata. Luxury cars have gone in the opposite direction: They made up 5.4 percent of the market last year, down from 7.5 percent four years earlier.

And the priciest S.U.V.s and trucks are selling fastest. The high-end Lariat, King Ranch and Raptor models make up more than half of all F-150 sales, up from one-third a few years ago. Denali editions account for 29 percent of GMC’s sales, up from 21 percent.

Low gasoline prices are one reason that sales of high-end trucks are rising. Years ago, pickups and big S.U.V.s often traveled only 11 or 12 miles on a gallon of gas. Today, their fuel economy is often double that.

“The complaint that S.U.V.s are horrible on gas is not such a roadblock anymore,” said Mark Scarpelli, owner of two Chevrolet dealerships and a Chrysler-Dodge-Jeep franchise in Illinois.

At the same time, automakers have appointed special-edition S.U.V.s and trucks with the same kinds of advanced technologies and comfort features that consumers once found only in luxury cars. Want an interior trimmed in African mahogany? You can get it in the Black Label Navigator. Want an S.U.V. that accelerates like a Porsche (and isn’t a Porsche)? Try the Jeep Grand Cherokee Trackhawk and its 707-horsepower V8.

Chuck Ducher, a retired school psychologist in Onsted, Mich., just bought an F-150 Lariat with a bevy of options, including heated rear seats. “I can put my mother back there, and she’s in heaven,” he said. “There’s no doubt in my mind this is a luxury vehicle.”

Wes Lutz, owner of a Chrysler-Dodge-Jeep dealership in Jackson, Mich., said he was surprised at the way customers were snapping up the most expensive models on his lot. This month, he had two Trackhawks this month, each with a sticker price of $93,000.

“They won’t be here more than a few weeks,” he said. “It’s incredible. We never used to play in that price range.”

Increasing competition from upmarket S.U.V.s and trucks is adding to the struggles of the luxury makers. Most have long relied on cars for the bulk of their sales, and are suffering now that bigger vehicles are in favor. In 2017, for example, BMW’s sales to individual customers at dealerships in the United States fell more than 5 percent, according data shared among automakers. The decline in BMW’s total sales was less because of a big jump in sales to rental car fleets, a type of customer that luxury brands tended to shun in the past.

Out in Tacoma, Wash., Gary Gilchrist sees the trend just about every week at his GMC dealership.

“We’ve been taking in Lexuses on trade-ins, BMWs,” he said. This month, he said, a customer turned in a 2012 BMW 550i and bought a $71,000 GMC Sierra Denali pickup.

“People used to want German cars for the image factor,” Mr. Gilchrist said. “Now, if you have a Denali, you get that. People turn their heads to look.”
 

mmcartalk

Expert
Messages
4,164
Reactions
2,677
Well, it's nice that people are giving more support to American-badges now. But, again, it sounds like the age-old practice of people not necessarily buying what they need, but an image factor to keep up wth the Jones's. And full-size pickups, despite their admitted usefulness and utility, can be a b**ch to maneuver and park at close quarters.
 
Messages
3,165
Reactions
3,785
Well, it's nice that people are giving more support to American-badges now. But, again, it sounds like the age-old practice of people not necessarily buying what they need, but an image factor to keep up wth the Jones's. And full-size pickups, despite their admitted usefulness and utility, can be a b**ch to maneuver and park at close quarters.
I think more Americans now are embracing large vehicles than ever before, whether they can be a PITA to park or not. BUT nowadays, back up cameras and all this technology are helping people drive. AND also, these technologies are no longer just found in high-end vehicles as well.

The fact that you can go to a dealer in your small Middle American town and buy one of these things is making those sales much more easier; a lot of these "Americans" probably live too far away from the import luxury dealership that's in most major metropolitan cities.

http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2018/02/domestic-luxury-trucks/
In my part of the world you have to drive 6 hours to get to the closest BMW or Mercedes dealership. GM dealerships dot the landscape. I do believe that sort of presence plays a huge roll in sales.

“These trucks are the Imperials, Caprices, Devilles, Roadmasters, Continentals, New Yorkers, and LTDs for today. The only thing that’s missing is a Ram tungsten Edition with Brougham package and Continental / Opera Light Kit.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: CIF

CIF

Premium Member
Messages
1,704
Reactions
1,863
A really illuminating article with a big dose of reality.

What is most concerning is that Toyota is either willfully or ignorantly giving away these sales and all this profit to American brands. Yes, there is the LX and GX on the Lexus side. They have both had some nice refreshes, but at the end of the day they are dated products. They also don't have a ton of options or variants. On the Toyota side, you have a decent number of options and trims available for the Tacoma, 4Runner, and Tundra. Except the problem is the Tacoma and 4Runner are too small for many people, and they don't have any super-luxury options or trims. The only Toyota truck/SUV with a super luxury trim is the 1794 edition Tundra, and to a lesser extent the Platinum trim Tundra. On the Sequoia side, the entire vehicle is extremely dated. The 2018 refresh did virtually nothing for the Sequoia. Even the Platinum Sequoia is still dated inside and out, and has few super luxury touches. Also unfortunately, all of these products are dated.

Yes there is also the Land Cruiser, but that is essentially sold as a mono-spec model. The Land Cruiser, like all the above-mentioned products, is also super dated not to mention just too expensive for most people. There used to be a time many years ago where Toyota was always able to predict and anticipate market trends. What happened to Toyota since then? Now Toyota seems to be constantly behind and on the back foot. At this point, I would have to say Toyota and Lexus look to be about 5-10 years behind the current market demand, if not more.

Hybrids, electric, hydrogen, plug in, autonomous, etc.... most of the market does not care about such products currently. Most of the market is demanding bigger, more powerful, more capable, tougher, and more luxurious trucks, SUVs, and crossovers. The F150 Raptor is a big hit, and Toyota offers nothing even close to this. Same thing for the incredible selection that the Grand Cherokee offers. Aside from a variety of regular trim levels the Grand Cherokee offers including the off-road oriented Trailhawk, there is the incredible new Trackhawk. Toyota does not offer anything even remotely close to this. The TRD Pro trims of some select Toyota trucks and SUVs are a nice small first step...but they offer no powertrain upgrades, and no luxury additions. The TRD Pro trims are purely just some off-road upgrades. Speaking of that, the new Colorado ZR2 is a direct competitor to the Tacoma TRD Pro, and it's been doing very well in comparisons vs the Taco TRD Pro. So Toyota was complacent for too long, and now suddenly the Tacoma does not look all that competitive. Rumors also indicate the Ranger Raptor trim that was unveiled overseas will be coming to North America as well. That will make things even tougher for the Tacoma.

As the article points out, the American brands are reaping the benefits of great image and marketing which are improving their reputations. It really is true that products like the F150 Raptor, Grand Cherokee Trackhawk, or Denali line of products carry great image and prestige currently. Further additions like the Grand Wagoneer, Bronco are only going to make things even more competitive for Toyota.

Toyota years ago gave up much of the off-road enthusiast market to Jeep. Now it's very clear that while Toyota is competitive at the low end and very high end of the market in terms of price ranges, the huge middle portion of the market is where Toyota has largely been a no show. The middle portion of the market (arguably the 50-70K or 50-75K USD range) is where the American brands have been really competitive over the last few years, and they are not letting up the pressure.

It pains me to say this, but as a Toyota/Lexus fan some of these American products are starting to appeal to me. I still have some major reasons against buying an American vehicle, but because Toyota is so uncompetitive in many ways with its trucks and SUVs currently, that is just the sad reality of it.
 
Last edited:
Messages
3,165
Reactions
3,785
A really illuminating article with a big dose of reality.

What is most concerning is that Toyota is either willfully or ignorantly giving away these sales and all this profit to American brands. Yes, there is the LX and GX on the Lexus side. They have both had some nice refreshes, but at the end of the day they are dated products. They also don't have a ton of options or variants. On the Toyota side, you have a decent number of options and trims available for the Tacoma, 4Runner, and Tundra. Except the problem is the Tacoma and 4Runner are too small for many people, and they don't have any super-luxury options or trims. The only Toyota truck/SUV with a super luxury trim is the 1794 edition Tundra, and to a lesser extent the Platinum trim Tundra. On the Sequoia side, the entire vehicle is extremely dated. The 2018 refresh did virtually nothing for the Sequoia. Even the Platinum Sequoia is still dated inside and out, and has few super luxury touches. Also unfortunately, all of these products are dated.
I agree a lot with what you said. I think right now is when Toyota could have invested even more heavily in their trucks to really reap the benefits that the Big 3 are doing now (yeah, eggs in one basket scenario). I would think with Toyota's refocus of giving more autonomy to its regions, they would have done more to the Tacoma and Tundra. While the Taco is doing fine, it will really need some better updates to better heed the GM twins and upcoming Ranger. Loyalty can only go so far in that segment, especially when many legacy Taco owners call the current one the "turd generation". Tundra isn't gaining much ground when the rest of the competition dictates the market here.

While the Camry is enjoying a lift being all new (at the moment), the Prius IMO was DOA, except for the Prime, but it can only do so much for a diminishing segment. I'm sure Toyota's money right now is on the RAV4 and Highlander. Personally, I'm hoping that the next 4Runner gets here soon because it gets a lot of respect from even the most anti-Toyota enthusiast.
 

CIF

Premium Member
Messages
1,704
Reactions
1,863
I agree a lot with what you said. I think right now is when Toyota could have invested even more heavily in their trucks to really reap the benefits that the Big 3 are doing now (yeah, eggs in one basket scenario). I would think with Toyota's refocus of giving more autonomy to its regions, they would have done more to the Tacoma and Tundra. While the Taco is doing fine, it will really need some better updates to better heed the GM twins and upcoming Ranger. Loyalty can only go so far in that segment, especially when many legacy Taco owners call the current one the "turd generation". Tundra isn't gaining much ground when the rest of the competition dictates the market here.

While the Camry is enjoying a lift being all new (at the moment), the Prius IMO was DOA, except for the Prime, but it can only do so much for a diminishing segment. I'm sure Toyota's money right now is on the RAV4 and Highlander. Personally, I'm hoping that the next 4Runner gets here soon because it gets a lot of respect from even the most anti-Toyota enthusiast.

Yes agreed. The new TNGA announcements from Toyota have given me hope we will be getting some significant new tech for Toyota's next-gen BOF vehicles. The only question is when. I don't really want to see Toyota rushing just for the sake of it, but man is patience a virtue when it comes to being a Toyota fan.
 

spwolf

Expert
Messages
3,582
Reactions
3,489
As the article points out, the American brands are reaping the benefits of great image and marketing which are improving their reputations. It really is true that products like the F150 Raptor, Grand Cherokee Trackhawk, or Denali line of products carry great image and prestige currently. Further additions like the Grand Wagoneer, Bronco are only going to make things even more competitive for Toyota.

Toyota years ago gave up much of the off-road enthusiast market to Jeep. Now it's very clear that while Toyota is competitive at the low end and very high end of the market in terms of price ranges, the huge middle portion of the market is where Toyota has largely been a no show. The middle portion of the market (arguably the 50-70K or 50-75K USD range) is where the American brands have been really competitive over the last few years, and they are not letting up the pressure.

It pains me to say this, but as a Toyota/Lexus fan some of these American products are starting to appeal to me. I still have some major reasons against buying an American vehicle, but because Toyota is so uncompetitive in many ways with its trucks and SUVs currently, that is just the sad reality of it.

All of Toyota trucks and suvs are "suffering" from them not being able to produce enough, except for Sequoia.
Highlander and 4Runner are enjoying record sales, same goes for Tacoma.

So their problem is not being able to satisfy the demand, not being "uncompetitive".

They will never be able to compete with F150, no matter how much they try.
 
Messages
3,165
Reactions
3,785
All of Toyota trucks and suvs are "suffering" from them not being able to produce enough, except for Sequoia.
Highlander and 4Runner are enjoying record sales, same goes for Tacoma.

So their problem is not being able to satisfy the demand, not being "uncompetitive".

They will never be able to compete with F150, no matter how much they try.
While I also agree they can only build as many as they can supply to the market, Toyota could well be able to sell an even more diverse line of SUVs. The only one that is hardcore is the 4Runner, so unfortunately when they stopped the FJC, there was no replacement then, which sucks because if the FJ sold now, the market would be brisk and much better than when it came first to market (which was during our economic crisis)...But yeah, there's a TJ or whatever that they've promised. But for Toyota, they will have plenty more competition now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CIF

spwolf

Expert
Messages
3,582
Reactions
3,489
While I also agree they can only build as many as they can supply to the market, Toyota could well be able to sell an even more diverse line of SUVs. The only one that is hardcore is the 4Runner, so unfortunately when they stopped the FJC, there was no replacement then, which sucks because if the FJ sold now, the market would be brisk and much better than when it came first to market (which was during our economic crisis)...But yeah, there's a TJ or whatever that they've promised. But for Toyota, they will have plenty more competition now.

Sure, but there will always be competition, their main problem even today is lack of production for existing SUVs and trucks, like Rav4, Highlander and Tacoma. But I guess it is not a horrible problem to have.
 

CIF

Premium Member
Messages
1,704
Reactions
1,863
All of Toyota trucks and suvs are "suffering" from them not being able to produce enough, except for Sequoia.
Highlander and 4Runner are enjoying record sales, same goes for Tacoma.

So their problem is not being able to satisfy the demand, not being "uncompetitive".

They will never be able to compete with F150, no matter how much they try.

Actually, if Toyota really wanted to give 100% effort, I argue they could easily compete with the F150. However I strongly believe as stated before that Toyota won't mainly due to political reasons, which I believe therefore leads to Toyota not having much will to compete so strongly in the truck segment.

Toyota has tons of truck experience with Toyota brand vehicles over the many decades. On top of that, Toyota has tremendous truck experience with the Hino division.

Also production issues for Toyota are not hard to fix when they want to. Toyota has the world's most flexible auto production system, and it doesn't take years and years and years to fix production issues...unless of course there are certain models in the lineup that Toyota is ignoring a bit.