Lexus EnthusiastLexus Enthusiast
  • Models
  • News
  • Forums
Menu
Models
Performance
GS F
IS F
LFA
RC F
Cars
CT
ES
GS
IS
LC
LS
RC
SC
SUVs
GX
LBX
LM
LX
NX
RX
RZ
TX
UX
News
Reviews
Rumors
Spy Shots
Videos
Renderings
Photo Galleries
Features
Forums
New posts
Search forums
Podcast

Auto Express Comparison Test: Lexus IS-F vs. BMW M3 vs. Mercedes C63 vs. Audi RS4

Kevin March 31st, 2008

Lexus IS-F vs. BMW M3 vs. Mercedes C63 vs. Audi RS4

Auto Express is the latest to pit the Lexus IS-F against the competition, throwing it into a test against the BMW M3, Mercedes C63 and the Audi RS4.

It’s almost a forgone conclusion that the M3 is going to place first, but Auto Express puts in a curveball, calling the Mercedes C63 the best of the test. And how did the IS-F fare?:

On a more fundamental level, the driving position is the least adaptable. The plush seats don’t hug you enough and you sit too high, so headroom is tight, while the chunky windscreen pillars leave you feeling hemmed in. And it’s not that spacious in the back, either.

But it’s pace, not practicality, that’s crucial here – and first impressions suggest the IS F is lacking. It was the quietest at idle inside and out, and its 5.0-litre seems like any other Lexus unit; effortlessly smooth, docile and calm. Don’t be fooled, though, because once the needle sweeps past 3,700rpm the 417bhp V8 takes on a whole new persona – there’s an instant hit of acceleration and the engine note, previously almost silent, becomes purposeful and loud.

Overall, while the Lexus is fast, composed and technically very capable in corners, it doesn’t quite have the handling of the M3, the fierce power, control and charisma of the C63 or the surefootedness of the RS4. Still, for a company with no previous experience in this segment, it’s a great achievement.

The more comparison tests that come in, the more clear it becomes that Lexus is going to be facing an difficult and lengthy uphill battle to establish the IS-F, but it certainly seems that they’re on the right track.

1st Generation Comparisons Competitors Lexus IS-F Videos

No discussion thread for this article yet.

Popular Stories
2025-11-27-GR-GT-2

Official: Toyota’s GR GT3 Concept will become the GR GT production car

Sorry Lexus fans, this supercar is going to be GR branded.
November 27th, 2025
2024-10-16-GT-GT3-Concept-3

Is this the new LFA? GR GT3 Concept Spied On Public Roads

Could this be a new Lexus supercar... or something different?
October 16th, 2024
2024-09-29-Lexus-Coupe-Concept-1

Should Lexus Resurrect the SC Coupe?

Speculation around a new midsize coupe feels like "SC" to us.
September 29th, 2024
2022-01-14-GR-GT3-Concept-3

A V8 Lexus LFR May Have Been a Pipedream After All

The GR GT3 Concept appears headed to production, but not as a Lexus.
October 10th, 2025
Follow Lexus Enthusiast
From the Forums
Official Lexus Future Product & Powertrain Megathread
3,522 replies
Last post by DarkSpace6383
2025 Updated CT5-V and Blackwing
5 replies
Last post by mikeavelli
GR GT Megathread (GT3 Concept will become the GR GT)
180 replies
Last post by Lexus Jack
IS 500 F SPORT Performance Megathread
1,021 replies
Last post by blackjack214
Toyota Yaris Master Thread (Sedan & Hatch Discontinued for USA)
335 replies
Last post by Motor
Toyota Land Cruiser FJ Discussion
53 replies
Last post by Motor
12th Generation E120 Toyota Corolla Thread (Hatch, Sedan, Cross, GR)
674 replies
Last post by Motor
2027 INFINITI QX65
12 replies
Last post by Motor

Latest Posts

  • DarkSpace6383 in "Official Lexus Future Product & Powertrain Megathread" 8 hours ago
  • mikeavelli in "2025 Updated CT5-V and Blackwing" 1 day ago
  • Lexus Jack in "GR GT Megathread (GT3 Concept will become the…" 3 days ago
  • blackjack214 in "IS 500 F SPORT Performance Megathread" 3 days ago
  • Motor in "Toyota Yaris Master Thread (Sedan & Hatch Discontinued…" 3 days ago
View All Forums →
Contact Privacy Policy
© 2026 Lexus Enthusiast